For businesses
Membership or loyalty card: which suits your business?
Mosey · 15 November 2026 · 11 min read

A loyalty card suits a business whose guests come often but unpredictably: it rewards visits they have already made and costs you nothing but the reward. A membership suits a business with a small group of regulars who would happily pay each month for a perk they will use. Most cafés and restaurants start with the card, then offer a membership to their best customers.
What is the real difference between a membership and a loyalty card?
Timing. A loyalty programme pays out after the guest has spent. A membership is paid for before they arrive.
With a loyalty card, the guest buys nine coffees and the tenth is free. You give something away only once they have already given you the trade. If they never come back, you have lost nothing. The card also does not change how often they come on its own. It gives a reason to pick you on a night they were undecided.
With a membership, the guest pays you a fixed amount each month for a defined perk, such as ten coffees or a free dessert on Fridays. You have the money before the visit, and the guest has already committed to you. The risk moves to you: if a member uses more than the fee covers, you carry the difference. That is why a membership needs a margin check and a loyalty card mostly needs a sensible reward.
A quick way to hold it in your head:
- Loyalty is a thank you. It follows the sale and rewards a habit that already exists.
- Membership is a subscription. It comes before the sale and tries to create the habit.
Neither replaces the other. They answer different questions, and the rest of this guide helps you pick the one your business needs first.
How does a loyalty programme work on Mosey?
You choose a programme type and a reward, and guests earn automatically. The types are a visit programme, a frequency programme (visit a set number of times in a week or month), a spend band, a tiered programme and an item stamp card, such as a free coffee after a set number. Each channel has its own switch: in store, Order Ahead collection, delivery, vouchers, catering and more. Loyalty counts the food, not the tax, and on a split bill each person earns for their own share.
At the counter, a guest taps their phone on your Mosey tag, or reads out a six digit code, and their card opens on the Counter screen. Your staff press Add visit or give a reward. The rules that protect you:
- A tap is a request, never a grant. Nothing is credited until your staff press the button. The exceptions are self check-in at an event door and a trail stamp, and both are off until you switch them on.
- Staff can undo an action for 15 minutes. After that, removing one needs the manage loyalty permission and a reason.
- A second visit on the same day is allowed. That is how regulars behave. Repeats within 30 minutes are shown to staff, not blocked.
- A refund takes back what the order earned, including a bonus from a boost.
Loyalty is free on every plan: no commission and no monthly fee. It needs no Stripe account: stamps, visits and rewards run at the counter without one, and only Mosey Pay needs one. You can also set a birthday treat and run bonus days. The loyalty programme guide and the feature page cover the set-up, so this guide stays on the decision.
How does a membership work on Mosey?
You start from one of six templates: a mug club, a coffee pass, a supper club, a founding member, a credit pass or a family plan. Each fills in perks and billing, and you can change every line. Guests join on a web page without the app, pay through your own Stripe account and can cancel online. A guest who cancels keeps their perks to the end of the period they have paid for.
As you build the plan, the dashboard runs a margin check. It assumes a heavy user who visits 20 times a month and uses every perk, counts free goods at 40 per cent of their menu price, and warns you if the perks could cost more than the fee brings in. It warns and does not block, so the sums are still yours to read.
Memberships have no monthly fee. Mosey keeps 8% of each membership payment, plus VAT at 23% on that fee, and Stripe's card fee is passed through at cost. You pay nothing until a member pays you, and the pricing page lists every rate. You can also send members up to four letters and one push notification a month at no charge, to members who agreed to hear from you.
The full decision on whether to launch one is in should your restaurant launch a membership, and the pricing steps are in the membership pricing guide.
What does each one cost you?
Compare the cost of the reward with what you take in. Here is an example with round numbers. They are an illustration, not a forecast, and your own prices and costs will differ.
Loyalty example. A coffee sells for €3.50 and costs about €1 in ingredients and a cup. The card gives the tenth coffee free. A guest who earns it has spent 9 x €3.50 = €31.50, and the reward costs you about €1 in goods plus the sale you did not make on a cup they might have bought anyway. That is a small share of what they spent, and it is only paid out to guests who came nine times.
Membership example. A coffee pass costs €30 a month and gives ten coffees. Ten coffees at €3.50 is €35 of menu value, but about €10 in goods. A guest who uses every coffee costs you about €10. What is left of the €30 has to cover the commission, Stripe's card fee, VAT and the time it takes to serve them. The margin check does that arithmetic for you before you go live.
Notice the shape of the two. The loyalty reward is small and paid late. The membership perk is larger, paid in advance and used often by the guests who value it most. A sensible cap, such as no more than one free coffee a day, keeps the membership fair to you. The perks guide shows how.
How do the two compare side by side?
| Loyalty programme | Membership | |
|---|---|---|
| When the guest pays | After each visit, as normal | Before the visit, each month |
| What the guest gets | A reward after enough visits, stamps or spend | A defined perk, from the first day |
| Cost to you on Mosey | Free on every plan, no commission | 8% of each payment plus VAT, no monthly fee |
| Risk to you | The cost of the reward | Perks that cost more than the fee |
| Commitment from the guest | None | A recurring payment |
| Best for | Frequent, unpredictable visits | A loyal core who visit often |
| Works with occasional guests | Yes | Rarely |
| Needs a margin check | Worth doing for the reward | Yes, before you publish |
| Cash flow | Nothing in advance | Money in before you serve |
| How guests join | In the app, once per programme | On a web page, no app needed |
Read the table as a trade. Loyalty is cheap and low-risk because the guest takes the first step. Membership brings income forward because the guest takes a bigger step.
Which one suits which kind of business?
Use this as a starting point, and trust your own knowledge of your regulars over it.
- A café or bakery with daily regulars. Start with an item stamp card on your coffee. It is easy to explain at the till. Then offer a coffee pass to the people already on their seventh or eighth stamp. The coffee club guide walks through it.
- A neighbourhood restaurant with a few repeat tables a month. A visit or spend programme works best, with a reward worth having after a few visits. Add a supper club membership only if you run regular events.
- A pub or wine bar with a loyal local crowd. A mug club is the classic membership here. A frequency programme is a lighter alternative if you would rather not hold money in advance.
- A food truck at a fixed pitch. A stamp card fits, because people come on the same days. A weekly lunch pass is possible if you serve the same crowd each week.
- A business that depends on one-off visitors, such as a café on a tourist street. A loyalty card will not pay back, and a membership will not sell. Put your effort into getting found and rated instead.
- A new business with no regulars yet. Start with a loyalty programme, because it needs no sales pitch. A founding membership can fund a launch later, once you know who your regulars are. See the founding drop guide.
How do you decide in ten minutes?
Answer these in order and stop at the first clear answer.
- Do most of your guests come once? If yes, neither will move your numbers much yet. Work on being found first.
- Could you name your twenty best regulars? If not, start with loyalty and let it show you who they are.
- Do they visit at least weekly? If yes, a membership has a real chance. If monthly, a loyalty reward is a better fit.
- Is your perk cheap to give and easy to cap? Coffee, a free dessert or a set number of items are. Open-ended discounts are not.
- Would you rather have money now or a reward later? If you need income ahead of a slow month, a membership does that. If you would rather not take on that risk, choose loyalty.
- Can your staff explain it in one sentence at the till? If not, simplify it before you launch anything.
If two of these point to membership, run the margin check on your own prices before you decide. If they point to loyalty, switch it on this week, since it carries no Mosey fee, only the cost of the reward.
Can you run both at once?
Yes, and many businesses should. Loyalty is free, and a membership is the paid version for your best regulars. A guest who has collected stamps for three months and keeps coming is exactly who to offer a membership.
Keep them distinct in how you describe them. The card says "buy nine, get the tenth free". The membership says "pay once a month, get ten coffees". If the two overlap in what they give, guests will ask which to choose and some will pick neither.
Watch the total generosity. Count the reward and the membership perk together for your best guest, and make sure the combined cost still leaves you a margin. The guide to which members are worth it shows how to read the numbers after launch. For the wider plan on bringing guests back, read how to keep more loyal customers and the guide to running a stamp card.
What should you tell guests, and what are their rights?
Say what the guest gets in one sentence, and say when a reward expires. A loyalty reward expires when you say it does, so put it on the programme.
For a membership, be plain about the price, what is included and how to cancel. A member who cancels keeps their perks to the end of what they have paid for. Guests also have rights you should know about. The Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC) says an online purchase of a service carries a 14-day cooling-off period, starting when the guest agrees the contract, and a guest who cancels pays for any part they have already used. On Mosey, a first membership cycle can be withdrawn within that window, and the refund is automatic only while no perk has been used. If a benefit has been used, the guest goes to you.
Do not rely on this page for your own terms. Write them in plain words, and check anything that matters with the CCPC or a solicitor.
What should you do this week?
- Pick one of the two, using the ten-minute list above.
- If loyalty: choose one programme, set one reward you are happy to give, and tell the first twenty regulars in person.
- If membership: pick the closest template, cap anything generous and run the margin check.
- Work out the reward or perk cost as a share of what the guest spends.
- Write your one-sentence pitch and practise it at the till.
- Review after six weeks: how many joined, how many came back and what the reward cost.
When you are ready, Host on Mosey free, connect Stripe and start with whichever you chose. There is more in the membership feature page, the guide to getting repeat customers and the guides for food businesses.
This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules change and depend on your business and where it is, so check the current rule with the official body named in the guide and take advice from a solicitor or accountant in your area before you act.
Questions
Common questions
What is the difference between a membership and a loyalty programme?
A loyalty programme rewards visits a guest has already made, such as a free coffee after nine. A membership is paid for before the visit, usually monthly, in return for a defined perk. Loyalty follows the sale. Membership comes before it.
Is a loyalty programme free on Mosey?
Yes. Loyalty is free on every plan, with no commission and no monthly fee. It needs no Stripe account, because only Mosey Pay does. The cost to you is the reward itself, so work that out before you set it.
What does a membership cost on Mosey?
There is no monthly fee. Mosey keeps 8% of each membership payment, plus VAT at 23% on that fee, and Stripe's card fee is passed through at cost. You pay nothing until a member pays you. The pricing page lists every rate.
Which is better for a small café?
Most cafés do best starting with an item stamp card, because it is free and easy to explain at the till. Once you know who your daily regulars are, offer them a coffee pass. Many cafés run both together.
Can I run a loyalty card and a membership at the same time?
Yes. Loyalty is free, and a membership is the paid version for your best regulars. Keep the offers distinct, and count the reward and the perk together so that your best guest still leaves you a margin.
Do I need a margin check for a loyalty reward?
It is worth doing. Work out what the reward costs you as a share of what a guest spends to earn it. A membership has a margin check built in that warns you as you build, and it assumes a member who visits 20 times a month and uses every perk.
What types of loyalty programme can I run on Mosey?
You can run a visit programme, a frequency programme, a spend band, a tiered programme or an item stamp card, such as a free coffee after a set number. Each channel, including in store, collection and delivery, has its own switch.
Can guests cancel a membership and get a refund?
A guest who cancels keeps their perks to the end of the period they have paid for. The 14-day right to cancel applies to a first cycle: on Mosey the refund is automatic only while no perk has been used. After that, the guest goes to you.
More like this
Read next
A hotel restaurant that locals use too
A hotel dining room earns local trade when it acts like a restaurant of its own. Here is why locals stay away, how to set the dining room up on Mosey beside your hotel, and which offers fill it.
An alcohol-free drinks menu that still makes margin
More guests are drinking less, in January and the rest of the year. Here is how to cost, price, name and sell an alcohol-free menu so it earns as well as the wine list, with the Irish VAT and offer rules checked.
A pub that does food: making the kitchen pay
A pub kitchen pays when its gross profit covers its own wages and running costs. Here is how to count it, which services to fill, what the alcohol rules say and how Mosey fits.
Auto-enrolment pension for Irish restaurants and cafés: what you pay and do
Since 1 January 2026 an Irish employer matches the pension contribution of each eligible employee. Here is who counts, what it costs on a wage bill, the payroll steps and what staff can opt out of.
Get started
Host your business on Mosey. It is free to claim.
Free to list, no set-up fee, and Order Ahead is 1.5% commission when you start taking orders.