For businesses
What to do about a fake or unfair review of your restaurant
Mosey · 15 November 2026 · 7 min read

When a review of your restaurant or café looks fake or unfair, check your own records before you react, report it if it describes a visit that never happened or breaks the rules, and reply once, calmly, for the people who will read it after you. You cannot make an honest bad rating disappear, but you can make sure the next reader trusts your answer more than the rating.
Why does one unfair review hurt so much?
Because you read it alone, usually after close, and it describes a night you remember differently. You know how hard the kitchen worked. The person who wrote it does not, and the person deciding where to eat tomorrow does not either.
That second person is the one who matters. They read the worst rating on your page and then read your answer. A rating with no reply reads as a business that did not notice. A rating with an angry reply reads as a business that argues with guests. A rating with a short, calm, specific reply reads as a business that is run by adults, and that is the reader you are writing for.
How can you tell a fake review from an angry one?
An angry review is usually specific. It names the dish, the wait, the table by the door, the price of the bottle. It can be harsh and still be true, and it deserves a real answer.
A fake review tends to leave fingerprints:
- No detail you can check. No dish, no day, no time, nothing about the room.
- Something you never did. A dish that has never been on your menu, or a Sunday lunch when you are closed on Sundays.
- No trace in your records. No booking, order or card payment that fits the name or the night.
- A burst. Several low ratings in a few days from accounts with no other history.
- Matching words. The same phrases turn up in more than one rating.
There is a third kind, and it is the most common: the unfair review. The visit was real, but the rating judges you on something outside your control, such as the rain, the parking or a dish they ordered and did not like the sound of. You do not report that one. You answer it.
What should you check before you do anything?
Wait an hour. Nothing you write in the first ten minutes will be the reply you want on your page for years.
Then check what you hold. Look at bookings for that day, orders, the till and the rota. Ask whoever was on the floor or the pass whether they remember the table. Ratings on Mosey are given dish by dish, often with a photograph, so you can usually match a rating to a real plate or see straight away that the plate never left your kitchen.
Write down what you found in two lines. It decides the next step: report, reply, or both.
What can you report, and what happens next?
You can report a rating that describes a visit that did not happen, is about a different business, is abusive, names or attacks a member of staff, or breaks the community rules in another way. You cannot report a rating because it is low or because you disagree with it, and asking for that wastes the goodwill of the people who read reports.
On Mosey, a report from you or anyone on your team does not take the rating down by itself. It goes to Mosey's moderation team, who look at it and decide. If they hide it, the person who wrote it is told and can appeal once. That keeps the system fair in both directions, which is the only reason a good rating on your page means anything.
If a rating accuses you or a named member of staff of something serious that did not happen, talk to a solicitor before you reply in public. Fake reviews are also a consumer protection matter, so check the current rule with the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC) if you believe a competitor is behind them.
How do you reply so the next reader sides with you?
Keep it to three or four lines, use the same calm voice every time and never argue facts in public.
When you have no record of the visit: "Thank you for the rating. We cannot find a booking or an order that matches this, and we would like to understand what happened. Please message us here and we will look into it."
When the visit was real but the rating is harsh: "Thanks for coming in. We are sorry the evening fell short. The rain on Friday did us no favours either. We would love another chance on a quieter night."
When they are angry and right: "You are right, and thank you for saying it. The fish should not have taken that long. We have changed how we fire mains on busy nights. Message us and we will put it right."
Do not offer a free meal in public, do not mention their booking or payment, and do not reply twice. The full guide to replying has scripts for good ratings too.
What if a rating names a member of staff?
Some ratings go after a person: the server who was slow, the chef who came out, the barista with the wrong attitude. Those hurt your team more than they hurt the business, and how you handle them tells your staff whether you have their back.
Talk to the person named before you do anything else. Hear their side in private, and check it against the rota and your records. If the rating is fair, the conversation is about what to do differently, not about the rating. If it is unfair or personal, tell them so, and report it: a rating that attacks a named member of staff is the kind the moderators look at.
In your reply, never name the member of staff, never blame them in public and never defend them in detail either. "We have spoken to the team, and we would like to hear more from you directly" covers it. Your staff read your replies too.
Does one bad rating cost you Mosey Gold?
Mosey Gold is earned from ratings alone. Nobody can pay for it, boost it or subscribe to it, and nobody can pay to outrank you on your town page: top spots come from ratings too. Gold is earned at one level and only lost below a lower one, so a single ordinary night cannot take it away.
The rules cut both ways. Ratings hidden after a report are left out of the score, ratings an owner leaves for their own business do not count, and nor do accounts the moderators have restricted. The Gold guide explains how it works.
How do you stop one review defining your page?
Bury it under honest ones. A page with a single one-star rating and nothing else looks like a warning. The same rating among forty warm ones looks like a bad night.
Mosey alerts owners and managers when a low rating comes in, so you see it the same day, and a weekly digest covers the rest. On the Reviews page you can ask your recent customers for a rating, once a week, with one button. You see how many were asked, never who. Use it after a good week. The guide to getting more reviews covers the rest, and photographs of your best dishes help people rate what they ate rather than the night they had.
Never ask staff, friends or family to rate you. It breaks the trust that makes ratings worth having, and an owner's own ratings do not count towards Gold anyway. Regulars are the people who rate you most fairly, and the guide to getting repeat customers shows how to grow them.
What should you do this week?
Open your ratings and read the three lowest. Check each against your records and decide: report, reply or both. Then reply to everything new from the last month, good and bad. When you want every rating in one place, with alerts, replies under your business name and a page that people find by dish, Host on Mosey free and claim your page. See how ratings work for diners and how customers find you.
More in the guides for food businesses.
This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules change and depend on your business and where it is, so check the current rule with the official body named in the guide and take advice from a solicitor or accountant in your area before you act.
Questions
Common questions
Can I get a bad review removed from Mosey?
Not because it is low or you disagree with it. You can report a rating that describes a visit that never happened, is abusive or breaks the community rules, and Mosey's moderation team decides whether to hide it.
Does reporting a rating hide it straight away?
Not when the report comes from your own business. A report from you or your team goes to Mosey's moderation team, who look at it and decide. If they hide it, the author is told and can appeal once.
How do I know if a review is fake?
Look for no detail you can check, a dish you never served, a day you were closed, no matching booking or payment, or a burst of similar low ratings from new accounts. A harsh but specific review is usually real.
Should I reply to a review I think is fake?
Yes, once, briefly and calmly. Say you cannot find a matching visit and invite them to message you. The reply is for the next customer reading your page, not for the person who wrote the rating.
Will one bad rating cost me Mosey Gold?
Not on its own. Gold is earned at one level and only lost below a lower one, so one ordinary night cannot take it away. It is earned from ratings alone, and nobody can pay for it.
Can I ask my staff to rate my restaurant?
No. It breaks the trust that makes ratings worth anything, and ratings an owner leaves for their own business do not count towards Gold. Ask real customers instead, once a week, from the Reviews page.
More like this
Read next
A hotel restaurant that locals use too
A hotel dining room earns local trade when it acts like a restaurant of its own. Here is why locals stay away, how to set the dining room up on Mosey beside your hotel, and which offers fill it.
An alcohol-free drinks menu that still makes margin
More guests are drinking less, in January and the rest of the year. Here is how to cost, price, name and sell an alcohol-free menu so it earns as well as the wine list, with the Irish VAT and offer rules checked.
A pub that does food: making the kitchen pay
A pub kitchen pays when its gross profit covers its own wages and running costs. Here is how to count it, which services to fill, what the alcohol rules say and how Mosey fits.
Auto-enrolment pension for Irish restaurants and cafés: what you pay and do
Since 1 January 2026 an Irish employer matches the pension contribution of each eligible employee. Here is who counts, what it costs on a wage bill, the payroll steps and what staff can opt out of.
Get started
Host your business on Mosey. It is free to claim.
Free to list, no set-up fee, and Order Ahead is 1.5% commission when you start taking orders.