For businesses

How to do a staff review in a café or restaurant

Mosey · 15 November 2026 · 7 min read

A staff review in a café or restaurant is a short, private sit-down with each person, twice a year, where you go over what went well, one thing to work on, their hours and training, and what they want next. It does not need forms or scores. It needs twenty quiet minutes, notes you can read back next time, and an owner who listens more than they talk.

A checklist of six things a short staff review covers: what went well, one thing to work on, hours and rota, training, what they want in a year, and anything they want to raise.

Why bother with reviews in a small team?

Because in a busy kitchen nobody has a real conversation during service, and the conversations at the end of a shift are about the shift. Without a set time to talk, the first time you hear that someone is unhappy is the day they hand in their notice.

A review is also where good work gets said out loud. Many hospitality staff go years without anyone telling them plainly what they do well. Hearing it, with examples, is one of the reasons people stay.

And it protects you. If you have raised the same problem twice, in writing, with a clear expectation, any harder conversation later is fair and on the record.

How often should you sit down with each person?

Twice a year works for most small teams, with a short check-in after a new starter's first month and again at three months. Put the dates in the diary at the start of the year so the reviews do not slip when the season gets busy.

Hold them at a quiet time, away from the pass and the till: a weekday afternoon, before service, with a coffee. Never straight after a hard shift, when everyone is tired and anything said sounds like blame.

Keep them short. Twenty to thirty minutes is enough. A review that takes an hour feels like a hearing.

Tell people a week ahead, and tell them what it is for. "It is a chance to talk about how things are going and what you want next" lands very differently from "I need to see you on Thursday". Many hospitality staff have only ever been called into the office for bad news, so say plainly that this is not that.

What should a review in a small team cover?

Use the same short list every time, so people know what to expect:

  1. What went well. Two or three specific things since the last review. Read them from your notes.
  2. One thing to work on. Only one, with an example and what good looks like.
  3. Hours, rota and time off. Are the hours right for them? Any pattern on the rota that is not working?
  4. Training. What they have completed, and what comes next.
  5. The next year. What do they want to be doing? The career paths guide shows how to turn the answer into steps.
  6. Their turn. Anything they want to raise about the business, the team or you.

Ask the person to think about the last three questions before you meet. You will get better answers.

Talk less than they do. A good rule is to ask a question and then wait. In a small team, people often take a moment to say the thing that matters, and it usually comes after the silence, not before it.

How do you give hard feedback after service?

Not during service, and not in front of anyone. In the moment, fix what has to be fixed for the guest and move on. Afterwards, or the next day, take the person aside.

Be specific. "You were slow" is a judgement. "Table six waited twelve minutes for their mains to be called, and the tickets were sitting on the rail" is a fact you can both look at. Say what happened, what the effect was, and what you need next time. Then ask for their side; there is often a reason you did not see.

Keep it about the work, not the person. And end with the next step, not with the problem.

Give praise the same way, in private and specifically, as often as you give criticism. A team that only hears from you when something goes wrong learns to dread the tap on the shoulder. A team that hears both trusts the hard feedback when it comes.

If the same issue keeps coming back, write it down after each conversation with the date and what was agreed. Before any formal step, such as a warning, read up on fair procedures and check the current rule with the Workplace Relations Commission.

What should you write down, and who can see it?

Write a short note after each review: the date, what went well, the one thing to work on, any training agreed, and anything they raised. Keep it factual. A note you would be uncomfortable showing the person should not be written.

Notes about staff are personal data. People have a right to ask to see what you hold on them, so keep notes accurate and store them securely. Check the current rule with the Data Protection Commission.

Read last time's note before the next review. Nothing tells a person you were listening like "Last time you said you wanted to learn the grill. You have done four Saturdays on it since. How does it feel?"

What do timesheets and training records add?

They turn the conversation from impressions into facts. Before the review, look at the person's hours over the last six months: are they getting the hours they asked for, or many more? Have they had the time off they requested? A person working far more than they want is a person close to leaving.

Look at their training too: what you assigned, what they completed and what is overdue. Overdue training is worth asking about gently: it is often a sign that someone has had no time on the rota to do it, which is your problem to fix, not theirs.

Look at the small facts as well: late starts, missed breaks, shifts swapped away. None of them is a verdict, but a change in the pattern is a good reason to ask how things are going. The allergen guide is a good reminder of the training every member of the team needs, whatever their role.

What should you do after the review?

Do what you said you would, quickly. If you agreed to change a pattern on the rota, change it on the next rota. If you agreed a course, assign it that week. A review that promises things and delivers nothing is worse than no review.

Send a short summary to the person within a day or two: what you agreed, the one thing to work on and the date of the next conversation. It gives them something to come back to, and it shows you took it seriously.

Check in before the next review. A two-minute word after a shift, such as "I saw you on the grill on Saturday, it looked much calmer", shows you are watching the thing you agreed on.

How does Mosey help you prepare for a review?

On Mosey, each person on your team has a staff record with their role, start date, contract and documents. Their clock-ins become timesheets you approve, and their leave requests and answers are kept, so before a review you can read their hours and time off for the last six months in one place.

Courses you assign to them carry a due date, and each one they complete ends with a certificate on their record. Agree the next course in the review and assign it from the same screen. See Mosey Courses for how courses work and pricing for what training your own team costs.

Where should you start?

Put a review date in the diary for each person on your team in the next two months. Use the six-point list on this page, and write the note on the same day. When you want hours, leave, training and staff records ready to read before each review, Host on Mosey free and switch on the staff tools. The guide to keeping staff covers what else keeps a team together, and the onboarding guide shows how to set up a new starter's first month.

More in the guides for food businesses.

This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules change and depend on your business and where it is, so check the current rule with the official body named in the guide and take advice from a solicitor or accountant in your area before you act.

Questions

Common questions

  • How often should a restaurant do staff reviews?

    Twice a year suits most small teams, with extra check-ins after a new starter's first month and at three months. Put the dates in the diary early so they do not slip in the busy season.

  • What should I ask in a staff review?

    Ask what they think went well, what they want to work on, whether their hours and rota suit them, what training they want next, what they want to be doing in a year and anything they want to raise.

  • How do I give negative feedback to a chef or server?

    Do it privately, away from service, and be specific: what happened, what effect it had and what you need next time. Ask for their side, and end with the next step rather than the problem.

  • Can staff ask to see their review notes?

    Notes about staff are personal data, and people generally have a right to ask to see what is held about them. Keep notes accurate and factual, and check the current rule with the Data Protection Commission.

  • Do I need a formal appraisal system for a small café?

    No. A short list of questions, a quiet twenty minutes and a written note after each meeting are enough for a small team. Consistency matters far more than forms or scores.

  • Can Mosey show a staff member's hours and leave before a review?

    Yes. Approved timesheets, leave requests and the courses each person has completed are kept on their staff record on Mosey, so you can read the last six months in one place before you sit down.

More like this

Read next

Get started

Host your business on Mosey. It is free to claim.

Free to list, no set-up fee, and Order Ahead is 1.5% commission when you start taking orders.