Food culture
How to decide what to order at a restaurant you have never been to
Mosey · 15 November 2026 · 5 min read
Last updated 15 November 2026

The quickest way to choose well at a place you have never been is to find out what the kitchen is proud of. Look at what other people photographed and rated there, notice what the menu leads with, check the specials, and ask the staff which dish they would order themselves. Then order the thing this particular kitchen is known for, rather than the dish you always order everywhere.
A place's rating is an average across its whole menu, and nobody eats an average. The gap between the best and the most ordinary dish on one menu is often bigger than the gap between two places, so choosing the plate matters as much as choosing the place.
Before you go: look at what people actually ate
The most useful information about a menu is not on the menu. It is in the photographs of the food other people ordered.
On Mosey, ratings come with photographs taken at the table, and when somebody rates a place they can name the dish they had. Those named dishes build a dish page for each plate: what it looks like when it arrives, what people who ate it thought, and what they paid where they said. A minute looking through them tells you three things:
- Which dishes people come back for. A dish that six separate people have rated and photographed is one the kitchen is getting right.
- Which dishes nobody mentions. A plate that has never been photographed at a place with forty ratings is telling you something too.
- Portion size and price. You can see whether a main course is a plate or a platter, and whether lunch will be fifteen euro or thirty.
If you want to work the other way round, starting from the dish and finding the place, finding a place by the dish covers that, and the dishes people have photographed in Dublin shows what people have been ordering lately, most recent first.
How to read a menu you do not know
When you are sitting down with no information at all, the menu itself still gives a lot away.
- Length. A short menu usually means a kitchen cooking what it is confident about, with fresher ingredients turning over quickly. A very long menu across several cuisines usually means some of it is made well in advance, and that the kitchen's attention is spread thin.
- What comes first in each section. Places often lead with what they want you to order.
- The specials. A specials board or a dish of the day is often where the cook's attention is: seasonal produce, something new, something they wanted to make. It is also where the best value can be.
- Where the detail is. A dish described with a named supplier, a specific cut or a technique has had more thought put into it than one described in three generic words.
- The thing that is out of place. A pizza place with one unusual pasta, a café with a single hot lunch dish: somebody fought for that to be on the menu. It is usually good.
- The name over the door. A place called after a dish or a style of cooking is telling you what it does best.
What to ask the staff
Asking "what is good here?" gets you a polite answer that everything is. Ask something they can actually answer:
- "What would you order tonight?"
- "What is the kitchen proudest of?"
- "What do regulars come back for?"
- "Is there anything that is particularly good at the moment?"
Most servers have eaten their way through the menu and have real opinions. A specific, enthusiastic answer is worth taking. A hesitant one, or a recommendation for the most expensive thing, can be quietly ignored.
Order what the place is for
The most reliable rule is to match your order to the kitchen. A fish place is at its best with fish. A bakery-café is at its best with what came out of its oven that morning. A place with a wood-fired oven wants you to order something that has been in it.
The common mistake is ordering the safe dish you have eaten everywhere else. Every kitchen makes a few things because customers expect them, and those are rarely where its effort goes. If you are only going to eat here once, eat what it is good at.
Sharing so you can try more
With two or more people, order differently from each other and share. It is the easiest way to try a menu properly on a first visit, and it removes the risk of one person getting the dish everybody else wishes they had ordered.
Small plates and sharing menus are built for exactly this. With a traditional starter and main format, just agree before ordering that plates go in the middle.
Ordering with allergies or dietary needs
If you have an allergy, tell the staff before you order, not after you have chosen. Places must be able to tell you which of the 14 regulated allergens are in each dish, and asking first means the recommendation you get is one you can actually eat.
The same goes for vegetarian, vegan or halal needs. Rather than asking what you can have, ask what they would recommend that suits you. You will get the dish they think is best, not the one that happens to qualify.
Once you have eaten: help the next person
The reason the photographs exist is that somebody before you took one. When you rate a place on Mosey, naming what you had is one extra tap, and a line about one dish ("the bread is the reason to come") is usually the most useful sentence on the page. The ratings page explains how it works.
If a dish you want has nothing on it yet, you get to be first, and that is genuinely useful: the dishes nobody has rated are exactly the ones nobody can decide about.
Next time you are choosing between two places, open both on Mosey and compare the plates, not the averages.
How this works in the app: Choose your food ahead.
More guides to read next:
More in the food guides and the ranked lists of places.
Questions
Common questions
How do I know what is good at a restaurant I have never been to?
Look at photographs of the food other people ordered, check which dishes come up again and again, and ask the staff what they would order themselves.
Is it a good idea to order the special?
Often, yes. Specials are frequently where the kitchen's attention is, using seasonal produce or trying something new.
What should I ask the waiter to get a useful recommendation?
Ask what they would order tonight, or what regulars come back for. Those questions get a real opinion rather than a polite one.
Does a short menu mean a better restaurant?
Not always, but a short menu usually means a kitchen cooking what it is confident about, with ingredients that turn over quickly.
How can I see what a dish looks like before ordering?
On Mosey, dishes that people have named in their ratings have their own pages with photographs taken at the table, plus what people thought and paid.
What if I have a food allergy?
Tell the staff before you choose. Places must be able to tell you which of the 14 regulated allergens are in each dish.
Can I find a place by the dish rather than the restaurant?
Yes. Searching for a specific dish is often a better question than searching for a cuisine, because it is the thing you actually want.
More like this
Read next
Dublin food markets by day: Temple Bar, Dún Laoghaire and Marlay Park
A guide to Dublin's weekend food markets: Temple Bar on Saturdays, the People's Park in Dún Laoghaire on Sundays and Marlay Park at weekends.
Eating out alone: how to find a good place to eat on your own
Which places suit one, where to sit, when to go and how to book a table for one. Eating out alone, done well, is one of the best ways to eat.
Food day trips from Dublin: where to go and how to plan the day
Towns you can eat your way round in a day from Dublin, by train or by car, and how to plan the day so the best meal is the one you chose, not the one you settled for.
Food festivals in Ireland: a year planner by month
A month-by-month guide to the best-known Irish food festivals, what each is for, and how to plan a trip around one without trusting an out-of-date date.