Tip pools in Toronto restaurants: writing a policy staff trust

Tips are a large part of what servers, bartenders and often kitchen staff earn in a Toronto restaurant, and Ontario protects them in its employment standards. Getting tips wrong is a legal risk and one of the fastest ways to lose good staff. Getting them right, with a clear and fair policy, is one of the cheapest ways to keep a team. The law itself is in the guide on Ontario tip law for restaurants; this guide is about designing and running the pool.

This is general information, not legal advice. Check Ontario's Employment Standards Act guide on tips, or ask a professional, before setting or changing a policy.

Can an Ontario employer keep or deduct employees' tips?

Generally, no. An employer cannot withhold tips from employees or make deductions from them, except in limited cases: deductions required by law, such as taxes, deductions authorized by a court order, and redistributing tips through a tip pool. There are also specific rules about processing fees on tips paid by card, so check the current guidance before deducting anything related to card payments.

Can an Ontario restaurant run a tip pool, and who can share in it?

Yes. An employer can collect tips and redistribute them among employees through a pool, and the terms can decide who takes part, how the pool is divided, how often it is paid and how the terms change.

Owners and managers are a narrower question. Owners, sole proprietors, partners and directors can share in a pool only if they regularly perform, to a substantial degree, the same work as the employees who share in it. An owner who works the floor as a server every shift is different from one who does not. If you are unsure where you stand, take advice before including yourself.

Do you have to post your tip policy?

Since June 21, 2024, an employer with a policy of sharing tips must post a copy of it in at least one place in the workplace where employees are likely to see it, and keep records for three years. A written, posted policy also prevents most disputes, because staff can see exactly how tips are shared.

How must tips be paid out in Ontario?

By cash, cheque or direct deposit. With direct deposit, the account must be one the employee chooses and in their name. Decide how quickly card tips reach staff, write it in the policy and stick to it. Long delays create mistrust even when every cent arrives.

How do you design a fair tip pool?

Answer four questions clearly:

1. Who is in the pool? Front of house only, or the kitchen too? Many Toronto restaurants include the kitchen, which helps keep cooks.
2. How is it divided? By hours, by role points or a mix.
3. How often is it paid? Each shift, weekly or with payroll.
4. How do the terms change? With notice and in writing.

Method	How it works	Suits
By hours	Shares follow hours worked	Teams with similar roles
By points	Each role weighted, times hours	Mixed front and back of house
By shift	Split among everyone on the shift	Small, stable teams

How should you explain the pool to new staff?

On their first day, in writing, with a worked example: a sample shift's tips, who worked, their hours or points and what each person received. Tell them where the policy is posted and who to ask if a payout looks wrong. Applicants ask about tips before they accept, and a clear answer helps you hire: "front and back of house share tips by hours worked" attracts people who value fairness.

How do you keep tip records that hold up?

Good records are how you show you followed the rules.

• Record tips by shift, split into cash and card.
• Record the pool calculation: the total, each person's share and how it was worked out.
• Record every payout, with the date, amount and recipient.
• Keep records for the period the law requires, alongside payroll records.
• Share the calculation with staff, so nobody has to guess.

Most disputes about tips start with a payout nobody could explain. A clear record, shared openly, prevents them. For how tips sit on payroll, see the guide on controlled and direct tips.

How often should you review the policy?

Once or twice a year, and whenever your team or the rules change. Ask staff for feedback privately. Small, announced changes are far better than a surprise on payday.

More from Toronto: TIFF and big event weekends and messaging customers under CASL.

More in the Canadian guides for food businesses.